Private Event Catering Services
Let The Penny Pub bring our delicious pub favorites and warm hospitality to your next private event or party. From corporate gatherings to birthday celebrations, we'll make your event memorable with our extensive catering menu.
Corporate Events
Impress your colleagues and clients with our professional catering service featuring crowd-pleasing appetizers, hearty entrees, and our famous wings that will keep everyone satisfied.
Birthday Parties
Make your celebration extra special with our party platters including sliders, chicken tenders, and our signature fried mac & cheese that guests of all ages will love.
Family Gatherings
Bring everyone together with our generous family-style portions of comfort food favorites, from loaded nachos to hearty quesadillas that create lasting memories.
Wing Platters
Our famous wings available in half or full trays with your choice of sauces
Slider Assortments
Cheeseburger and chipotle chicken sliders perfect for any crowd
Appetizer Platters
Mix and match from mozzarella sticks, pretzel sticks, and our signature fried sides
Fresh & Made to Order
All catering items are prepared fresh using our signature recipes and quality ingredients
Flexible Portions
Half and full tray options available to accommodate groups of any size
Easy Ordering
Simple online ordering or call us directly to customize your catering package
Local Bay Shore Favorite
Trusted by the community since the early 1900s for quality food and service
