A hand dips a crispy orange snack stick into creamy white sauce. In the background, a drink and various appetizers are visible.

The Best Pour In Bay Shore Since 1908

We've been bringing people together for over 100 years, serving cold beer, late night food, and creating lasting memories in our cozy neighborhood pub.
A plate of crispy chicken wings glazed with sauce, accompanied by celery, carrots, and a small cup of white dressing.

Monday Night Trivia

Test your knowledge every Monday night! Join us for a fun evening of brain teasers, great food, and friendly competition with your neighbors.

Fried macaroni and cheese wedges served with a dipping sauce on a plate. The wedges are golden brown and crispy, revealing a creamy macaroni filling.

Whiskey Down Wednesday

Midweek just got better! Join us every Wednesday for special whiskey deals and a relaxed atmosphere perfect for unwinding.

A plate of loaded fries topped with cheese, bacon bits, and two dollops of whipped cream. The fries are crunchy and appear indulgent.

Daily Specials

Something special every day of the week! From happy hour deals to chef's specials, there's always a reason to visit The Penny Pub.

A plate of quesadillas cut into wedges, served with two dipping sauces: one creamy and one ranch-style.

Kitchen Open Late

Hungry after midnight? No problem! Our kitchen stays open until 3am or later, serving up delicious pub favorites when you need them most.

A platter of crispy chicken pieces drizzled with a creamy sauce and a spicy sauce, layered artistically on a white plate.

Can't Make It? Get It Delivered

Craving our famous fried mac and cheese or a perfectly poured Guinness? Order online and we'll bring The Penny Pub experience to you.

Three pieces of fried fish on a plate, accompanied by a small cup of yellow dipping sauce.

Upcoming Events

From live music to special celebrations, there's always something happening at The Penny. Check out what's coming up next!

A plate of assorted fried snacks including golden nuggets and a side of white dipping sauce.

Let Us Cater Your Next Event

Perfect for holiday parties, work events, game nights and more. Pick up or delivery available for all your catering needs.

Penny Reuben

Connect With Us - Always at The Penny

Follow us on Facebook and Instagram to stay updated on daily specials, events, and all the fun happening at Bay Shore's favorite neighborhood pub.